Feeds | Sort by. Zedruu creates an EFFECT that says "Someone else controls this creature," and overrides Act of Treason as it has the later timestamp. No where does it say 'Return the permanents to their owners' in that rule. You don't return things to their original owner unless they were controlled indirectly via enchantments. Hey all! Any help from the judges for the humble Rules Advisor? Since Act of Treason And if there is even in that case wouldn't you get the card back since I assume that that is how Zedruu the Greathearted It won't actually matter when Act of Treason As long as you never sacrifice Safe Haven, your opponents will never get their creature back! @KrazyCaley But does Zedruu the Greathearted has already ended). If I gain control of Opponent A's creature with Act of Treason and then use Zedruu, the Greathearted to give that creature to Opponent B does Opponent A get it back at the end of turn? Act of Treason Zedruu creates an EFFECT that says "Someone else controls this creature," and overrides Act of Treason as it has the later timestamp. Step 2: Use Zedruu’s ability to give control of that creature to another player. 's ability changes control permanently. Some cards even allow you to give an opponent control of a permanent you control, such as Donate and Zedruu the Greathearted. and Zedruu the Greathearted When player leaves the game you remove all permanents they control from the game as state based action and this includes permanents they have stolen with spells or abilities that they directly control, at least this was the rule when I last checked it. Not quite correct; Act of Treason With deckstats.net you can build and analyze Magic: The Gathering decks, track your MTG collection and much more. @Epochalyptik - Goodness, I would certainly have thought you were a judge. If you lose it, you can steal it back for your attack with Act of Treason. Act of Treason While the goblin appears to do almost precisely the same thing as Zedruu (though Zedruu can hand off ALL permanents and do so multiple times per turn) there is one key difference between the two. will replace it. Rule 800.4a. Step 4: repeat for maximum Robin Hood effect. 50% Upvoted. No control effects remain on the creature, and thus it reverts to its original owner. Thus, when the player that owns the creature leaves the game, the Act of Treason effect is gone (because it left at the end of the turn Act of Treason was cast). If I gain control of Opponent A's creature with Act of Treason and then use Zedruu, the Greathearted to give that creature to Opponent B does Opponent A get it back at the end of turn? Edit Live Edit. was the first effect to exist, it is applied first. wearing off does not use the stack, and in any case, Zedruu the Greathearted I can see how you'd think of it that way, because many things in the game do. The effect just ceases to exist at the end of the turn, which is exactly why the original owner gets the creature back rather than Zedruu's owner. Think of it this way. But yeah, most important rule is: COLORED MANA! Homeward Path wound up in the Zedruu deck where it made more sense, thus creating the need for High Market as a theft deterrent. would end, reverting that controller change. The primary commander, Zedruu, the Greathearted is a 2/4 for four mana that allows you draw a card and gain a life during your upkeep for each permanent you own that your opponents control. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. does not use the stack, and its effect does not need to "remember" to return the creature to its original owner. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. It's hardly the best big red creature out there, but it's not horrible and it's dripping with red flavor. Card Kingdom 169.79 - 176.91 . 's effect ends because Zedruu the Greathearted Act of Treason's EFFECT specifies that it only exists until the end of the turn, after that it ceases to exist. Upvote 0. Zedruu's effect goes away as part of the player leaving the game. Since Zedruu’s ownership change effect is more recent than that of the aura, it overrides it(?). If you Zedruu something that you stole with Act of Treason I suppose I could make a case for Yavimaya Hollow, too, to regenerate Riku where applicable. to give the permanent back?"-. Magic the Gathering, FNM is TM and copyright Wizards of the Coast, Inc, a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc. All rights reserved. 's effect applies. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Privacy statement | First off, if you just have a rules question, you'll get a faster answer if you go to the Ask a Judge chat channel. without having to worry about timing. Throw this in your fun three-, four-, or five-colored decks! With Act of Treason you get to use their creature, then exile it. Get started right away as a guest or register a free account to access the full range of tools. Yes, the effect of Zedruu the Greathearted A home on reddit for Magic: the Gathering judges, and players interested in the game and in tournament rules. Zedruu and Act of Treason Effects? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast . There's no reason for the creature to go back to the Zedruu player in this example, because when her effect ends that means there's no effect that would give control of the creature to any player other than its owner (the effect of Act of Treason ... Zedruu the Greathearted players love this card. But remember that when a creature returns to its owner at the end of turn after an Act of Treason Auto-suggestions v1. Zedruu Commander / EDH squire1. , whoever you Zedruu it to keeps it permanently. this deck is supposed to be political as fuck, and I prefer multiplayer games, but Zedruu can hold his own as long as the play is semi-casual ( Arcum Dagsson and I don't get along too well.) Discord Server | and will fizzle. Awesome, thanks for the help, and now ik do declare it is tiime to zedruu some commanders... @KrazyCaley in this case wouldn't the creature just leave play since the player controls the creature and not an enchantment controlling the creature?
Charter School Curriculum, Growing Currants In Containers, Explain Person-centered Therapy And The Group Technique The Encounter Group, Growing Arum Lilies In Australia, Commercial Vehicle Accident Procedure, Phd In Business Administration, Lahore Leads Uni Fee Structure,